We are undoubtedly entering a historic period in the annals of climate history.
Momentum is building toward the Copenhagen climate negotiations in December, where-many hope-the nuts and bolts of a new international climate change framework will be negotiated. There is a growing sense of optimism in the air. Some are hopeful that, this time, the international community will actually forge a workable climate treaty. The source of this optimism? For one, the world has learned its lessons from past failures, including the Kyoto Protocol and a number of regional initiatives (such as Phase One of the European Emissions Trading System, ETS). Furthermore, thanks to continued scientific research and concerted efforts to inform policymakers and the public, the science of climate change has become ever starker; the policy options, clearer; and the willingness to include critical sectors like deforestation and land-use change, much stronger.
But perhaps most importantly, this time the United States may finally be on board.
This marks a remarkable sea-change for a country that, just three years ago, had a President whose official stance on global warming was flippant if not blatant denial. The dramatic shift of tide is exemplified by the recent and historic passage of the ACESA (American Clean Energy and Security Act, 2009) in the House of Representatives. Though by no means a perfect bill, it sets a declining cap on carbon emissions. Total greenhouse gas emissions will be reduced to 17% below 2005 levels by 2020 and 73% below 2005 levels by 2050[1]. The scale of proposed reductions, though not particularly ambitious, is still probably compatible with staying within 2 degrees Celsius (C°) or fewer of planetary warming by 2100[2]. The heart of the plan is a cap-and-trade scheme that would induce an economically efficient reorientation of the American economy toward a more climate-friendly trajectory. According to some estimates, all of this could be achieved at the price of mere pennies a day for the average American consumer[3]. Until this year, not a single bill proposing concrete action had gathered anything close to the number of votes needed for passage in either the House or the Senate.
And despite the necessarily domestic scope of the bill-it only imposes caps on U.S. emissions-it is clear that domestic action on climate change has profound international implications. Many believe it is critical for the U.S. to have an established domestic commitment on climate change in order for it to have a real say at the negotiations in Copenhagen. After all, compared to many other countries in the rich world, the U.S. is embarrassingly late to the game. The European Union is already in the second iteration of its European Emissions Trading scheme (ETS), and has recently announced an EU-wide target of 20% reduction in greenhouse gases and a 20% share of renewable energy in total energy consumption by 2020[4]. Japan and Canada have also expressed similar goals and set up voluntary carbon markets domestically. Even Brazil has committed to a 70% reduction in deforestation-and the emissions that result from it-by 2018. By establishing a domestic cap-and-trade system for carbon, the U.S. may finally send the signal to other countries that it is serious about climate change.
If indeed the U.S. is taking climate mitigation seriously, it comes not a moment too soon. Despite the sheer difficulty of long-term climate projections, it is becoming increasingly clear that the consequences of “business-as-usual” are profoundly bleak, and that the costs of delay could be massive. As the synthesis report of the Copenhagen Climate Congress illustrates, the damages associated with rising temperatures may be much greater than previously estimated and will only grow with longer inaction. Postponement of mitigation entails greater and more rapid temperature increases, higher adaptation costs, and the locking in of high-carbon infrastructure that delays clean technological development and makes it more costly overall[5]. Furthermore, delay in curbing emissions increases the danger of irreversible “climate shocks”-the melting of the Greenland ice sheet, for example-that could adversely affect the global economy in a very serious way. Indeed, the new report suggests that the warming scenarios for business-as-usual appear more likely to be on the higher end of previous projections, meaning greater potential for catastrophic damages than scientists had expected before.
A growing number of world leaders, policymakers, and even businesses-not just in the rich world but in developing countries too-are becoming increasingly aware of these risks, as well as the rewards for acting sooner rather than later. They are calling for immediate action. Many seem willing to get going with economically feasible carbon-saving projects on the ground-the so-called “low-hanging fruit”-even in the absence of an overarching international framework. Indeed, there are many emissions-reducing solutions like insulation improvements, sugarcane biofuels, and energy efficiency improvements of old appliances that have a negative net cost of deployment (relative to existing uses or technologies). That is, they make economic sense even without an international carbon market[6]. In most cases, the barriers to adoption of these technologies are mostly informational (people just don’t know about them), inertial (old habits die hard), or financial (some people, especially in developing countries, don’t have access to the credit necessary to make the up-front investment). These are projects that we can get started on regardless of what happens in international talks. The UN Foundation, along with many other NGOs, is currently pushing for just that with its “building blocks” approach[7].
But most countries seem to be waiting for America to take the lead in achieving an international agreement-a viable successor to the Kyoto Protocol.
This makes the passage of ACESA all the more critical. If it is approved by the Senate and enacted into law by President Obama, the ACESA would finally put the U.S. on a path of declining emissions and would no doubt motivate many other countries (notably China, now by volume the world’s largest emitter) to follow. It would make a working international agreement in Copenhagen much more likely.
These are big ifs. In the Senate, the bill will most likely require a 60 vote majority to pass without a filibuster. Considering the much stronger rural bias in the Senate and the sway of energy lobbies in coal-rich Southern states, this passage will not come easily.
But a no-vote on this bill would be a signal to the world that the U.S. still does not recognize the urgency of climate change mitigation. In that case, there is little chance that developing countries such as China and India will find it politically feasible to sign on. Their line of argument is quite predictable: “You guys are responsible for most of the greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to date. We are still trying to play developmental catch-up. Why should we do sign on to mandatory reductions when you, the richest country in the world, won’t?” If the U.S. has no internal commitment to cut carbon, this point would be hard to rebut.
Yet, on the flip side, the size and scale of America’s potential carbon market means that passing a domestic cap-and-trade bill now would give the U.S. tremendous leverage, putting the ball squarely in the developing countries’ court. As Nathaniel Keohane of Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) puts it, if the United States signals that it is committing to emissions reductions now, others will perceive that “the train is finally leaving the station, and everyone will be haggling over the terms on which they will board it, rather than waiting to see what we do.”
Clearly, a lot is at stake in the next few months’ Senate hearings. There is a pressing need for ordinary citizens-the general public-to be more vocal. On an issue as pervasive and inter-generational as climate change, it is our responsibility not to simply stay mum. The reason why legislation in the U.S. has historically been so hard to pass- even the House bill passed by the slimmest of margins, 219 to 212-is not because there is any real debate over the need for curbing climate change. Rather, most of the obstacles are imposed by vested interests trying to minimize their share of the burden. Lobbies from coal and oil companies that stand to lose out from such a bill are the ones who yell the loudest in opposition (and financially can afford to send their envoys to Washington). Politicians naturally hear them. What politicians seem to have a harder time hearing is the diffuse yet pervasive appeal of the average citizen who knows she will end up footing the bill both for the costs of containing climate change and the damages that it will wreak if left unchecked.
So what to do?
We must demand that the current climate bill does not get watered down in the Senate by more concessions to industry and coal lobbies. Politicians and policymakers feel it when the public eye (and ire) is on them. They are just as likely to dodge hard choices when our attention wanders elsewhere. Referring to the necessity of getting this bill passed, Thomas Friedman, columnist for the New York Times, makes a particularly impassioned appeal: “You want to make a difference? Then get out of Facebook and into somebody’s face. Get a million people on the Washington Mall calling for a price on carbon. That will get the Senate’s attention. Play hardball or don’t play at all.”
He is right. These are matters that will determine the state of the planet for decades to come, with profound consequences for current as well as future generations. There is not a single person alive today who does not have a stake in tackling climate change. It is incumbent on all of us to care.
[1] According to estimates put forth by the World Resources Institute (WRI), however, the actual realized reductions have the potential to be even higher, up to 33% by 2020 and 81% by 2050, if we take into account performance standards for uncapped sectors and other provisions.
[2] That is, assuming that other countries carry through with their existing pledges, and developing countries eventually sign on to some cuts as well, sometime around 2020.
[3] A recent report by Nathaniel Keohane and Peter Goldmark of EDF finds that, for the US, the median impact on annual GDP growth of capping greenhouse gases amounts to three-hundredths of a percentage point (0.03%), or less than 1% of average household spending (Keohane, 2008). An analysis by the State Department shows similar findings.
[4] European Union: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2009:140:0063:0087:EN:PDF
[5] See Synthesis Report – Climate Change: Global Risks, Challenges and Decisions. Copenhagen 2009.
[6] See: McKinsey Co. “A Cost Curve for greenhouse gas reduction” 2005.
[7] For more details, see: “Practical Strategies for immediate progress on climate change” at www.unfoundation.org
viagra for woman
Chewable Viagra herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra
Ladies Viagra viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra 100mg "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Buy Cheap Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Viagra Without A Prescription viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Buy Viagra Meds Online snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra Prices viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
"generic viagra in british columbia"
Viagra Rrp Australia Cost can i take viagra
"viagra how does it work"
Viagra Soft Tabs herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Online Viagra Store viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra Online Stores "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra Herb Alternative generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
california phentermine network dish viagra
Viagra Low Cost viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums India Viagra snorting viagra health
viagra para mujeres
Low Cost Viagra Online viagra anxiety
taking viagra after the expiration date
Viagra Rx cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Non Prescription Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Buy Viagra Ups herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Levitra Vs Viagra viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra Alternatives "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra For Sale Without A Prescription generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Buy Viagra In Canada viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Soft Viagra snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Natural Viagra viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Where To Buy Viagra cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Canadian Pharmacy Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Prescription For Viagra herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Viagra Professional viagra patent levitra
Viagra andnot generic viagra animate 836.
How Does Viagra Work "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Over The Counter Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Canadian Viagra viagra how it works
"herbal viagra cartridge"
Buy Cheap Viagra Online snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra Online Uk viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Female Viagra cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Discount Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Buy Viagra Online 35008 herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health Buy Viagra Online Without Prescription viagra patent levitra
Viagra andnot generic viagra animate 836.
Viagra Order Uk "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra Buy generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Women Viagra viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums Online Viagra snorting viagra health
viagra patent expire
Viagra Patent Pfizer viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra From India cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Cheap Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra Oral herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Viagra Pharmacy viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra Prescription "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra On-line generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Viagra In Manchester Uk viagra how it works
"herbal viagra cartridge" snorting viagra health
viagra para mujeres
Viagra Over The Counter viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra In The Uk cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Generic Viagra Overnight can i take viagra
viagra how it works
What Is Generic Viagra herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health Buy Viagra In England viagra patent levitra
Viagra andnot generic viagra animate 836.
Viagra And Cialis "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Buy Viagra Cheap generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Viagra Vs Cialis viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Viagra Suppliers snorting viagra health
viagra patent expire
Purchase Viagra viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Cheapest Viagra Prices cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra Equivalent can i take viagra
"viagra how does it work"
How To Buy Viagra herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Buy Viagra Australia viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Buy Cheap Viagra Online Uk "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra Dosage generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra Cheapest Place To Buy Viagra Online viagra how it works
"herbal viagra cartridge"
Viagra Cialis snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Cost Of Viagra viagra anxiety
taking viagra after the expiration date
Cheap Generic Viagra cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra For Women can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra For Woman herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Viagra Erection Duration viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
cheap generic kamagra kamagra uk viagra
Alternative To Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
What Does Viagra Do viagra how it works
"herbal viagra cartridge"
Buying Viagra In Uk snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Buy Viagra On Line viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra Next Day cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra Purchase can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra No Prescription herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Fake Viagra Prescription viagra patent levitra
Viagra andnot generic viagra animate 836.
Viagra Facts "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Order 50mg Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Viagra In China viagra how it works
"herbal viagra cartridge"
Natural Viagra Substitutes snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra Mail Order Uk viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra Soft cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra From Usa can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Sublingual Viagra herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra
Natural Herbal Alternatives To Viagra viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Buy Viagra "taking viagra woman"
cheap generic kamagra kamagra uk viagra
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
california phentermine network dish viagra
Viagra Mexico viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Generic Viagra India snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra Discount viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra Online cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Suppliers Of Viagra In Uk can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Cheap Cheap Viagra herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Buy Viagra Online At viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Buy Viagra Order Viagra "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Buy Viagra Soft Online generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Purchase Viagra Online viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Professional Viagra snorting viagra health
viagra patent expire
Cheapest Uk Supplier Viagra viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra For Sale cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Generic Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Order Viagra herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra
Purchasing Viagra In The United Kingdom viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Cheap Viagra Online "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
california phentermine network dish viagra
Viagra On Line viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
How To Get Viagra snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Guaranteed Cheapest Viagra viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Buy Generic Viagra cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Buy Viagra Online Uk can i take viagra
viagra how it works Mexican Viagra herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra
Viagra Overnight viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Generic Name Of Viagra "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Cheap Herbal Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
c20 viagra
Viagra Stories viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Mexico Pharmacy Generic Viagra snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Cheap Viagra Canada viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra Store In Canada cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Where Can I Buy Viagra Online can i take viagra
viagra home page
On Viagra herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra Does Viagra Work viagra patent levitra
Viagra andnot generic viagra animate 836.
Buy Viagra In London England "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
U 3312 Viagra Cialis generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Viagra Alternative viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Cheap Viagra Walmart snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra Versus Cialis viagra anxiety
taking viagra after the expiration date
Generic Viagra Mexico cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra Doseage can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Buy Viagra Online herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Viagra Pills viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra Pill "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra Uk generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra Viagra Without Prescription viagra how it works
"herbal viagra cartridge"
Viagra Prescription Uk snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Buying Viagra Online viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Mail Order Viagra In Uk cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra Australia can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra Effects herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra
Viagra Covered By Insurance viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra No Prior Prescription "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
No Prescription Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Order Viagra Online viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Viagra Canada snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Low Cost Viagra viagra anxiety
taking viagra after the expiration date
Viagra And Blood Pressure Meds cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Super Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Legal Viagra herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Buy Online Viagra viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra Women "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Can Women Take Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
california phentermine network dish viagra
Herbal Viagra viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Viagra Online Cheap snorting viagra health
viagra patent expire
Cialis Or Viagra viagra anxiety
taking viagra after the expiration date
Pfizer Viagra cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Cheapest Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra Oral Jelly herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Viagra 34434 viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Generic Brands Of Viagra Online "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra Lawyers generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Lowest Price Viagra viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Viagra From Canada snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra 50 Mg viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Buy Viagra Per Pill cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
U 5672 Viagra can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra Generic herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Buying Viagra viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Viagra Next Day Delivery "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Womens Viagra generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Viagra Sales Uk viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Buy Viagra Online Australia snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Generic Mexican Viagra viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Uk Viagra Sales cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Herbal Viagra Australia can i take viagra
"viagra how does it work"
Viagra Price herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Viagra Jelly viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Can Viagra Be Taken By Women "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Cheap Viagra Tablets generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Lowest Price Generic Viagra viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Cheapest Viagra In Uk snorting viagra health
viagra patent levitra
Viagra Prescription Medication viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra Sales cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra Sale can i take viagra
viagra how it works Womans Viagra herbal viagra forums
smooth muscle piperazine viagra
Female Version Of Viagra viagra patent levitra
viagra anxiety
Cialis Viagra "taking viagra woman"
cheap gerneric viagra,
Viagra Sales Online In Uk generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
can i take viagra
Levitra Versus Viagra viagra how it works
herbal viagra forums
Buy Viagra Online 35008 Buy snorting viagra health
viagra para mujeres
Mail Order Viagra viagra anxiety
"taking viagra woman"
Viagra Uk Cheap Purchase Buy cheap gerneric viagra,
generic viagra levitra and cialis pills!
Viagra Cheap can i take viagra
viagra how it works
Viagra Canadian Pharmacy herbal viagra forums
snorting viagra health
Price Of Viagra viagra patent levitra
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.